web space | free hosting | Web Hosting | Free Website Submission | shopping cart | php hosting

Business Continuity Disaster Recovery COOP Crisis Management John Glenn CRP MBCI

lighthouse
January 8, 2006

 

    Get it right - the first time

ChiTrib Dewey Defeats Truman faux pax


John Glenn, MBCI
Certified Business Continuity Planner


The tragedy at the Sago Mine near Tallmansville, WV on January 3, 2006 and the rumors that followed point up once again the criticality of communications in a Business Continuity plan.

It also points out that no matter what the news, timing can turn an event into a "loose-loose" situation.

 

To tell or to wait for confirmation

    To tell or to wait for confirmation One of the lessons which should have been learned was that rumors are a disaster waiting to happen. Negative rumors and positive rumors have the same effect.

    Jack (Joe Friday) WebbAs an old newspaper reporter and editor, I know very well that rumors - even well-intentioned ones - can play havoc with peoples' lives. Smart journalists - and that excludes the ones such as the Chicago Tribune reporter, editor, and headline writer who "gave" the 1948 election to Dewey - make certain they have, in the immortal words of Jack Webb's Detective Joe Friday, "just the facts, ma'am." 1

    Countering rumors is one of the Fourth Estate's 2 primary functions.

    While Business Continuity planners are not journalists - albeit they may have a newspaper background - they must share the journalist's awareness of the damage rumor can cause.

    One of the sad lessons learned in West Virginia is that people need reassurance that something is being done. The old saw "no news is good news" is not acceptable in a crisis.

    Business Continuity plans lacking a communications ingredient a plans with a gaping hole.

    There are many parts to the communications ingredient, including:

    • Who talks to whom
    • What can be said
    • Scheduling release of information

 

Who talks to whom

    This is not a question.

    Each organization has multiple audiences who want, need, or simply deserve to know what's happening and what can be expected.

    First and foremost, the organization's responders need to know how to respond.

    Certainly there are - should be - response plans for various "scenarios." In a "worst case" scenario, the facility "goes away," the response plan may call for a determination of damage then a management decision to restore or walk away, perhaps starting over elsewhere or, perhaps, throwing in the towel - shutting down the organization.

    All employees need this information, and they need it as quickly as possible. That does not necessarily mean while the ashes still are hot, but "as soon as possible" and always within 24 hours. Not knowing if a job will be there tomorrow is more traumatic than knowing a job has been lost.

    If the decision is to walk away from the operation, there should be a policy and procedure known to all personnel from their employment Day 1 so they will know what to expect as severance.

    If the decision is to rebuild elsewhere, personnel need to be told what to expect - everyone who wants to relocate will receive relocation assistance, those who don't will receive severance, etc.

    If the decision is to rebuild locally, policies and procedures known to all personnel from employment Day 1 will spell out compensation arrangements - overtime and compensatory time for responders, furlough pay for those told to stay at home.

    For all the policies and procedures, management should reinforce the information with both verbal and written statements to personnel and their families. This must be done before any public statements are made which relate to personnel.

    The community in which the organization needs to know what to expect. Local media are the best tools for this. Since the media probably won't wait for a damage assessment, the organization should have a boilerplate (prepared) statement to the effect that "We must evaluate the damage before we can make any commitments; we expect to have the evaluation completed within (time frame)."

    Make certain the deadline can be met. If the deadline is missed, tell the audience why it was missed and set a new deadline. The second deadline must be met.

    When to talk to the media? That depends on the media. If there is a local morning newspaper, talk to the media in the afternoon. If the paper hits the streets in the afternoon, try to meet with reporters as early in the day as possible. The news will make the local TV evening and night news, but the newspaper will still have a "first day" article. TV and radio can provide almost instant sound bites and film clips, but the newspaper is still the only vehicle for in-depth coverage.

    Vendors and major clients/customers should be notified that an event occurred and that the damage is being evaluated. As with the local media, tell the audience when it can expect a decision on the organization's future.

    Lenders also have a right to know what happened and what will happen. Ideally, lenders will learn about the event from organization management rather than the media.

    While it is possible to tell the same story to each audience, it is better to tailor the story to each audience's interest. Likewise, it may be advisable for different people to deliver the story.

    For example, the organization's Chief Financial Officer (CFO) or other senior executive involved with the organization's finances is the prime candidate to talk to the financial community.

    The Chief Executive Office (CEO) or Chief Operating Officer (COO) should talk to the organization's staff. The task should not be delegated to HR or disseminated via mid-level managers; employee morale is important.

    What about executive level spokes folks who lack the ability to speak to the public? With the exception of the organization's personnel, professional spokesmen and spokeswomen from the organization's communications department can speak for the organization. No matter how poorly a C*O's presentation skills, a trusted C*O should be the one to talk to the organization's personnel. The employees may already know public speaking is not the executive's forte.

 

What can be said

    The first rule for spokes folks is NEVER LIE.

    Lies always are discovered and the price to be paid for the fabrication will be dear.

    An organization must "speak with one voice" even if there actually are several "voices."

    Everyone - personnel, media, lenders, clients - need to understand that the only information they can depend upon comes from an "authorized spokes person." Rumors are one of an organization's worst enemies; this was sadly proven in Tallmansville where a rumor gave the miners' families false hope, hope that was dashed with resulting anger and depression.

    A good communications plan includes "fill-in-the-blanks" scripts for the most common events and for serious incidents. Those events and incidents are identified in the Business Continuity plan's Business Impact and Risk Analyses. For the Three Mile Island nuclear generator near Harrisburg PA, the list would include a reactor accident; a call center would have different items on its list.

    The scripts should include anticipated questions or be very clear that questions will not be entertained by the spokes folks.

    Scripts should be developed as part of the organization's response plans and be vetted by Legal. It is advisable to have line managers review the scripts to assure they are technically accurate.

    If pressed for information beyond the script, the spokes folks must hold firm. They may tell the interrogator they will check and get back to the person, but a time should be set for the next meeting. As with all deadlines, if it looks like a deadline will be missed, tell everyone before the deadline and set a new deadline which will be met "no matter what."

    Did I mention NEVER LIE?

 

Scheduling release of information

    The nature of the event determines the frequency of releases.

    In an unfolding crisis such as the Sago Mine disaster, scheduled announcements should be frequent. Once the crisis has passed, the frequency of announcements can be extended.

    The loss of a facility may require multiple announcements on the first (crisis) day, and perhaps a once-a-day announcement for the first week.

    The audience for progress reports helps determine the reports' frequency.

    Organization personnel need daily updates. Clients may need weekly updates.

    Regulators will demand updates on their own schedules.

    Each release should include two things:

    • the time of the next release
    • a reminder that only releases from the organization are valid; rumors should be considered baseless until they are investigated by the organization's personnel.

    Rumors always will be with us; Business Continuity planners must work to assure counter-measures are included in the Business Continuity plan and that these measures are as exercised and maintained as every other part of the plan.


For some facts on "just the facts," see http://www.snopes.com/radiotv/tv/dragnet.htm Return to text

The term Fourth Estate refers to the press, both in its explicit capacity of advocacy and in its implicit ability to frame political issues. The term goes back at least to Thomas Carlyle in the first half of the 19th century. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_estate) Return to text

 

 


John Glenn, MBCI, has been helping organizations of all types avoid or mitigate risks to their operations since 1994. Comments about this article, or others at http://johnglenncrp.0catch.com/ may be sent to JohnGlennCRP @ yahoo.com.

 

biz card

 

© 2006, John Glenn MBCI